Harvard Creates Science and Religion Chair

Theologian Harvey Cox, who chronicled the risingsince the 1990s.
popularity of religion studies in his 2004 book When"I'm a big believer in the proposition that science and
Jesus Came to Harvard, may need to write a sequel:religion are complementary and not contradictory, and
When Jesus Came to Harvard and Taught Science.I am much concerned about the fact that the world
That's because Harvard Divinity School, where Coxlooks at each differently," said Watson, a managing
teaches, has accepted an endowment from alumnuspartner of Spieth, Bell, McCurdy & Newell Co., a
Richard T. Watson to create a Professorship ofCleveland law firm, and a chancellor of the Episcopal
Science and Religion. The school is now searching forDiocese of Ohio. "This gift is designed to attack that
a visiting professor in science-and-religion for theconflict."
2006-2007 academic year.Greg M. Epstein, who as Humanist chaplain at Harvard
The appointment, so far, has caused few ripples -- ahas found himself at the center of such conflict,
noticeable change from 2002, when thereacted to the news with caution. "I think the idea of
Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics drewstudying science and religion is one that can lead to
protests after inviting physicist and Anglican priestuseful academic scholarship and the enrichment of an
John Polkinghorne to speak on intelligent design.entire scholarly community but may very well not --
This time around, theologians were predictablydepending on how the project is framed," said
encouraged, Harvard scientists were standoffish butEpstein.
pleasant, and secularists warily expressed a glimmerSome wondered about how much latitude the
of hope that such a professorship might lend supportprofessorship should be allowed. "If [Harvard Divinity
to their causes.School] gives the scholar free rein, then the
The Watson professorship is the latest in a series ofpossibilities of religious naturalism might get explored
similarly prestigious posts that began with Princetonat a prestigious university, which will show HDS as
Theological Seminary's 1992 appointment of J.being on the progressive cutting edge of religious
Wentzel van Huyssteen as the first James I. McCordstudies," said Thomas W. Clark, director of the
Professor of Theology and Science. OxfordCenter for Naturalism in Somerville, Mass. "Of course,
University followed suit in 2000 with the appointmentsaying that the mandate is to study science and
of John Hedley Brooke as its first Andreas Idreosreligion as complementary suggests that the conflict
Professors of Science and Religion. Others includebetween science and faith-based religions might be
Marquette University's 2001 naming of Jame Schaeferpapered over or finessed, which would be too bad,"
to a newly created science and religion professorshiphe said. "But pseudoscience isn't about to gain
and the 2005 appointment of Andrew Lustig totraction at Harvard, which is why the new chair won't
become Davidson College's first Holmes Rolston IIIreflect badly on any of its science or medical
Professor of Religion and Science.departments."
"The research grant and endowment for aFor many Harvard scientists, there is, in fact, a role
religion-science professorship affirm the ongoingfor science-and-religion studies at the university -- as
interest in relating the disciplines as a bona fide fieldlong as it remains at the Divinity School and does not
of academic inquiry," said Schaefer. "Harvard joinsseep into the research labs and lecture halls.
Princeton and other major universities in the world inDaniel Hartl, a Harvard biology professor who
exploring the religion-science relationship in aspecializes in evolution and population genetics, said
prestigious way."he does "not perceive any particular conflict between
The news comes on the heels of a $1.5 million grantscience and religion, at Harvard or anywhere else, as
from the Pew Charitable Trusts to a University ofone is a matter of evidence and the other is a
Missouri religion research center to study thematter of faith."
relationship between religion and health care, andBut although there seems to be little grounds for
other topics. (See "Other schools encouragebelieving in a higher being, there is room for such a
dialogue.") It also comes as the John Templetonprogram at the university, said James Hanken, also a
Foundation, which funds Science & TheologyHarvard evolutionary biologist. "Your day-to-day
News, makes a grant to Harvard Divinity School andactivities of your average Harvard scientist won't be
the university's Faculty of Arts and Sciences to studyaffected," he said.
the origins of altruistic behavior and their relationshipWatson hopes to change that. "Those are the people
to biology, theology and ethics. The John Templetoninto whose minds I would like to creep," he said.
Foundation has been making such grants to Harvard